Holiday Fun: Fantasy College Football Bracketology

December 16, 2010 | Glenn Clark

It’s Holiday season. Let’s have a little fun today.

Like every other red-blooded American, I’m no fan of College Football’s BCS system. In fact, I believe the approval rating for the BCS actually just somehow dropped lower than Barack Obama’s.

The best playoff proposal I’ve ever heard for a NCAA Tournament at the FBS level is a 16 team format that includes all conference champions getting automatic bids. I don’t know who to credit with coming up with the idea, so I won’t bother. The idea is that you include all conference champions, then fill out the other remaining seeds via final BCS rankings.

Were a tournament in place this year, these teams would be automatic qualifiers:

Auburn (SEC)
Oregon (Pac 10)
TCU (MWC)
Wisconsin (Big Ten)
Oklahoma (Big 12)
Boise State* (WAC)
Virginia Tech (ACC)
UConn (Big East)
Central Florida (Conference USA)
Miami (Ohio) (MAC)
Florida International (Sun Belt)

*Technically Nevada won the WAC’s tiebreaker system, as they and BSU finished with better overall records than Hawaii; but they beat the Broncos head to head. However, this tournament would adapt the rules that all conferences determine non head-to-head tiebreakers by BCS standings; which is a system already in place in the Big Ten. Thus, Boise State qualifies.

and the following teams would be at-large qualifiers…

Stanford
Ohio State
Arkansas
Michigan State
LSU

Therefore setting up a 16 team tournament that would look something like this…

(1)Auburn (SEC)
Game 1 Details
(16)Florida International (Sun Belt)
(2)Oregon
Game 5 Details
(15)Miami (Ohio) (MAC)
Winner of 1
Game 9 Details
Winner of 2
Winner of 5
Game 11 Details
Winner of 6
Winner of 9
Game 13 Details
Winner of 10
Winner of 13
Game 15 Details
Winner of 14
Winner of 11
Game 14 Details
Winner of 12
(8)Arkansas
Game 2 Details
(9)Michigan State
(7)Oklahoma
Game 6 Details
(10)LSU
(4)Stanford
Game 3 Details
(13)UConn (Big East)
(3)TCU (Mountain West)
Game 7 Details
(14)Central Florida (Conference USA)
Winner of 3
Game 10 Details
Winner of 4
Winner of 7
Game 12 Details
Winner of 8
(5)Wisconsin (Big Ten)
Game 4 Details
(12)Virginia Tech (ACC)
(6)Ohio State
Game 8 Details
(11)Boise State (WAC)

Pretty good looking Tournament, huh? Games could start next weekend after finals, with the Championship Game being played somewhere around Martin Luther King Day. It would be only about a week longer than the season is right now.

So here’s your chance to fill out the bracket. Thanks to Bracketmaker.com, you can click HERE and decide how you think it would play out. OR you could leave your thoughts here in the comments.

Me personally, I still have Cam Newton and the Tigers beating the Ducks in the title game out in Glendale…

(1)Auburn (SEC)
Game 1 Details
(16)Florida International (Sun Belt)
(2)Oregon (Pac 10)
Game 5 Details
(15)Miami-Ohio (MAC)
Auburn (SEC)
Game 9 Details
Arkansas
Oregon (Pac 10)
Game 11 Details
LSU
Auburn (SEC)
Game 13 Details
Virginia Tech (ACC)
Auburn (SEC)
Game 15 Details
Oregon (Pac 10)
Oregon (Pac 10)
Game 14 Details
Ohio State
(8)Arkansas
Game 2 Details
(9)Michigan State
(7)Oklahoma (Big 12)
Game 6 Details
(10)LSU
(4)Stanford
Game 3 Details
(13)UConn (Big East)
(3)TCU (Mountain West)
Game 7 Details
(14)Central Florida (Conference USA)
Stanford
Game 10 Details
Virginia Tech (ACC)
TCU (Mountain West)
Game 12 Details
Ohio State
(5)Wisconsin (Big Ten)
Game 4 Details
(12)Virginia Tech (ACC)
(6)Ohio State
Game 8 Details
(11)Boise State (WAC)

(Editor’s note: In my tournament theory, teams are slotted to bowl games as they are eliminated. It isn’t a PERFECT theory, but we’re comparing it to the BCS. The BCS is TERRIBLE. This is better.)

ATLANTA - DECEMBER 04: Quarterback Cam Newton  of the Auburn Tigers celebrates with the crowd after the 2010 SEC Championship against the South Carolina Gamecocks at Georgia Dome on December 4, 2010 in Atlanta, Georgia. The Tigers beat the Gamecocks 56-17. (Photo by Mike Zarrilli/Getty Images)

Your thoughts? Have fun with this today…

-G

Comments on Facebook

Comments are closed.