I don’t know what Klinsmann is doing; I hope he does

May 23, 2014 | Drew Forrester

I don’t know what Klinsmann is doing; I hope he does

Jurgen Klinsmann should know better than this, but he obviously doesn’t.

He should know that you can’t win World Cup games on hope.

He should know that you can’t win World Cup games with youth.

He should know, because he’s been there, that come World Cup time, the cream always rises to the top.  And, in soccer terms, cream equals experience.

Klinsmann shocked the U.S. soccer world yesterday by cutting veteran Landon Donovan from the team’s roster for the upcoming World Cup in Brazil.  Instead, the coach kept the likes of 18 year old Julian Green, whom many believe is the offensive wizard the U.S. has been trying to produce for the last fifty years.  There were other head-scratching “keeps” by Klinsmann, including 20-year old defender DeAndre Yedlin, but none created a buzz like Donovan’s departure did when it was announced late Thursday afternoon.

Donovan has been in and out of Klinsmann’s doghouse for the last two years or so, at one point taking a self-imposed “sabbatical” from soccer to discover if, in fact, he really did love the game.

He returned last year to help get the U.S. into the 2014 World Cup, playing a significant role in qualifying games as well as the Gold Cup.

When healthy, the 32-year old Donovan can still make a major contribution.  It might not be for a full 270 minutes in the three group games the U.S. team will face next month, but if Klinsmann thinks he’s going to get more out of the likes of Green and newcomer Aron Johannsson, he’s kidding himself.

Lots of folks think Klinsmann is merely playing the “youth card” in an effort to groom those inexperienced kids for Russia 2018.  Some look at yesterday’s moves as a concession by the coach that the U.S. — facing the “Group of Death” at Brazil — is facing an uphill battle in 2014.

Jurgen Klinsmann is crafty.  That’s how he was as a player and he’s been that way as a coach, too.  There’s no logical explanation for the moves he made yesterday.  Perhaps he’s trying to create a built-in excuse for next month when/if the red-white-and-blue gets spanked out of the first round of the World Cup — “we had to get those kids some experience, even at the expense of this year’s tournament”.

That’s malarky, of course, and Klinsmann is smart enough to know that.  The World Cup comes along every four years.  Unless you host the event, you don’t even know if you’re playing in the event when it comes around.  There’s never, ever an excuse for “planning for next time”.  Not when it comes to the World Cup.  You bet your best 23 players out there and go balls-to-the-wall to try and escape Group play and give yourself a chance at advancing.

Yesterday’s decision to leave Landon Donovan off the roster hurts the U.S. chances next month in Brazil.  He would have added a midfielder who keeps the ball and distributes it with equal effectiveness.  He changes the play to the weak side as well as anyone and can move up to forward in more of a withdrawn, supporting position and suffer little change in his contribution.  And, as he showed in 2010 when he scored a last-gasp goal against Algeria to send the U.S. to the knock-out round, Donovan can score goals as well as create them.

He’s no longer the captain of the team, so it’s not like this exclusion means the U.S. has to quickly figure out who their new team leader is, but everyone in the locker room knew what they would be getting from Donovan, whether he provided 90 minutes or 18 as a late-game substitution.

No one knows what to expect from the likes of Green or Johannsson, because neither of them has any experience at this level of play.

This will go down as a colossal mistake by Klinsmann, but something tells me he might know that going in.

Perhaps he knows something we don’t about his 2014 World Cup team.

One thing for certain; he better be right with this decision.  If not, he’ll get the blame.

Comments on Facebook

5 Comments For This Post

  1. John In Westminster Says:

    I’m going to treat this like I would any player moves done by Ozzie with the Ravens. Just as Ozzie has built perennial contender with the Ravens, so Klinsmann has done with Germany and now he’s trying to do so with the US mens team. Also, we really don’t know the relationship between Klinsmann and Donovan or the possible power struggles between them. While I like Landon, he’s part of the old Arena/Bradley teams that ruled CONCACAF but never really contended at the world stage.

    Jurgen is a proven winner as a player and manager and it appears that he’s went shopping for his groceries and will now prepare the meal his way. It seems obvious he’s building for the future which I don’t mind, because we’ll be lucky to come away with 2 points in the group stage this year. Frankly, I like the chemistry of some of the other players like Zusi, Dempsey, Diskerud, and Altidore better. I doubt guys like Green will get more than 5 minutes on the field anyway. But, if we keep pushing the same guys out there, like Donovan, we can’t expect to do better than we’ve done in previous World Cups. Klinsmann doesn’t just want to compete. Rather, he wants to contend.

    (Bias disclosure: Yes, outside of the US, I’ve always rooted for Germany. Lothar Matthäus was one of my favorite players growing up.)

  2. Jason Manelli Says:

    A slap in the face to Donovan and the achievements of USA soccer over the last 15 years.

  3. charlie Says:

    it’s all about 2016. anyway, in jurgen we must trust.

  4. Bill Gross Says:

    In the 70th minute and we’re down a goal to the Germans and Jurgen looks to the bench for a sub to look into the fire and score a goal, who will it be? Certainly no one with the class and skill as Donovan. Five goals in 12 Cup games, more than the 3 that Rooney, Messi, Ronaldo, and Ibrahimovic have scored in 31 games COMBINED. Bruce arena said it best, if we have 23 players better than Donovan the U.S. should win the World Cup. I hope Klinsmann is right, that’s all I can say.

  5. Tim Says:

    Bill, great points. Need to have Donovan available as a spark from the bench late in the game.

    Yet, it does remind me of something a coach like Billick would do – take the focus off the players and put it on him.

    Without Donovan, all the focus is on Klinsmann now.

Leave a Reply